Probably the most common comment we see coming through on our quote request form is “Gosh, you sound very well-spoken. I bet you’re devilishly attractive as well.” And it’s true, everyone involved is both stunning and witty. But that’s not really relevant to this post. This post is all about the second most common thing that comes up, which can basically be summarised thus:
“I did a comic and I want to print the comic so that I can sell the comic to all my friends and fans but I don’t know how to go about printing the comic because I have never printed a comic before HALP.”
It’s usually phrased better than that, but that’s the gist. The point is, we get a lot of first time comic printers round these parts, and there are a few things that come up often enough to warrant a general advice post. This post is going to be very specifically focused on the final stage in getting your comic out there – printing and selling the thing. I’m not going to cover:
- How to learn to draw. (I cannot draw).
- How to learn to write. (I also cannot do this – that should be obvious by now).
- How to get a contract working for Marvel or DC off the back of your comic. (I’m pretty sure this never happens – it certainly shouldn’t be your only aim. You should be creating your own comic for the love of it, dude).
What I am going to cover is:
Knowing your market
This is the key thing to think about, but so often people seem to forget about it. OK, you have this awesome idea for a comic, and you’re pretty sure that it’ll sell. C’mon, if it was already on sale you’d buy it! Surely that’s proof that it’s a great idea?
No. Sorry. You need some data there. Otherwise you run the risk of ending up with a bunch of comics that you’ve paid for and no outlet to sell them. That’s going to be crippling to both your bank account and your self-esteem, so let’s try and avoid it, shall we?
So how do you generate the data to prove that you have a market? Well, there’s a bunch of ways, but they all boil down to:
HAVING A DECENT WEB PRESENCE
I’ve put it in bold and all caps. That’s how important this is. It’s the single best way to find out if people like your comics and will pay for them. If you’ve got a regular webcomic you can track the hits you get, you can communicate with your fans and ask them if they’d like to see your work in print, you can sell things online (which is much less satisfying than going to Thought Bubble and blowing through all your stock in one go, but much more stable as a long term strategy that doesn’t call for you to attend every convention in the world). There’s a lot you can do with a regularly updated webcomic.
If you don’t have the time or energy for a rolling serial comic, or if that format doesn’t really match up to what you’re trying to create, a web presence is still essential. For instance, have you heard of Kickstarter? I’m betting you’ve heard of Kickstarter… Do you know what’s so brilliant about Kickstarter for comic creators? Everything. Everything about it is brilliant. A successful KS campaign gives you:
- Money! Sweet, sweet money. Money that isn’t coming from your own pocket to pay for the printing costs. Risk free money!
- Proof of market. KS is essentially a pre-order system at base. Your backers are definitively telling you that they like your idea enough to lay down cash for it even though they haven’t seen the product. If you meet your funding goals you know you’re onto a winner.
- A solid contact base to build on. These people who are telling you that they like the cut of your jib? They’re probably going to like the cut of your next jib as well. All of a sudden you’ve got a fanbase, kiddo. You’re a star!
At some point we’ll get a post up about how to build a successful Kickstarter campaign (or we’ll ask one of our many crowd-funded customers to do it for us). But that’s for another day. Moving on, let’s have a look at:
Knowing the scene(s)
Have you been to any conventions? Do you know which creators are big names amongst their peers? Have you joined the Comic Village Alliance on Facebook yet? Have you spent any time around your local comic book store and got chatting to staff and regulars? How about Twitter – who are you following in the small press scene and how are you getting your stuff out there using social media? And what about reviews? You’re gonna want to have your comic reviewed by one of the respected blogs out there, for sure. Do you know how to make that happen? (Actually, that last one has been made a little easier for you by this excellent article from Andy Oliver over at Broken Frontier which says many of the things I’m saying here, but better. Go read that instead.)
My point is, even if you’ve got a fully-funded Kickstarter and a billion pre-orders, you can’t stop there if you want to make this work. Becoming relevant is hard, but it’s wasted effort if you’re not going to work to stay there. That means getting to know the key players in the small press scene, engaging with the community & your fans & always looking to the next project. It can be tiring (or so I’m told) but it’s a lot of fun.
Learning the schedules for conventions will pay dividends – there’s no point having a bunch of books ready to sell and missing all the cons because you didn’t book in time. It’s also worth keeping an eye on what other creators are saying about specific conventions so that you can pick and choose which to attend. Different cons have different audiences, and there’s no point you turning up with your horror comic to a con that mainly caters to a family audience now, is there?
Update: a brief digression on conventions.
Since this post was originally written the number of UK conventions has expanded from “a lot” to what scientists are calling “approximately all”. There is a frankly staggering number of cons of various shapes, sizes, flavours, and specialities to pick from these days.
Some cons will fill up really quickly because they have strong reputations, some will be new additions to the scene and worth a look to get in before they really take off; there’ll be a con that maybe isn’t for everyone, but serves the niche your comic fits really nicely. There’ll be one near you that’s worth checking out as a toe-dipping exercise. There’ll be a few that curate their attendees list & require submissions for consideration by the organisers (including, from 2016, the granddaddy of them all – Leeds’ mighty, mighty Thought Bubble). All of them will have different cut off dates for applications, different pricing structures, and different rules on what you can and can’t do. This, for new creators, can be a bit intimidating.
Which is why everyone owes Luke Surl a debt of gratitude. Because he’s made a very helpful thing that you can take advantage of. That thing is ComicShowTables and if you’re interested in the scene you should absolutely go and subscribe to it right this minute. Once subscribed you’ll get emails from show organisers letting you know when tables become available to book, meaning you can beat the rush. You’ll also be among the first to know about newer shows, giving you more options for places to sell. It’s really a great idea – I wish I’d thought of it. Thanks, Luke!
End of digression
There are a load of people who can give you much better advice on life as a creator than me, so I’ll leave this here (do check out all the links, though). Finally, we’re going to take a look at the boring stuff – the technical stuff – the stuff I’m good at…
Nuts and bolts
So here are three of the most common issues that come up for first time comic printers:
- Imaginary numbers
- Scheduling problems
- Lack of technical knowledge
There’s a pretty simple solution to all of these problems, which is “leave a lot of time and ask a lot of questions”. A really good comic book printer will work through all the issues with you as long as you’ve got the time and are clear with them, but there are a couple of general bits worth covering here – forewarned being forearmed and all that…
Have you thought about your costs and how you’re funding this? No, but really. Like, REALLY thought about it. Because if you haven’t you’re in for a world of hurt. We’ve seen all sorts: people who took a guess at how much they thought printing would cost, factored it into their KS campaign without checking, met their funding goal, and discovered that they’d under-budgeted by about 50%; people who did a “test the water” print of 50, paid a really high cost per unit as a result, and had to come back the next week for another run because they hadn’t figured how high demand would be; we’ve even had people who deliberately sold one of their books as a loss leader and couldn’t work out why they were losing money (it was because everything else looked overpriced in comparison). These are extreme examples, but they do happen – don’t let them happen to you.
There’s a general rule which holds firm throughout the printing world: “More is less”. Or, to put it another way – costs per unit go down (pretty dramatically in some cases) as the number of units rises. Now this is where knowing your market comes in – we try to help by giving prices on two or three quantities for every quote that we send out, but we don’t know what your audience is. If you sell yourself short by ordering 50 copies, only to discover that you have 100 customers, you’re going to end up robbing yourself of profit that you could be using to fund your next project.
Now I get that it’s scary to lay out the money for 100 copies when you’ve only made 45 presales so far. I get that. But look deeper. How long did it take you to make those presales? Has the flow dried up or is it still coming? If you’ve been running presales for two months, got to 45, and haven’t had any new orders in the last fortnight then sure – go ahead and order 50. But if you started taking orders last week and are still getting in the occasional order (one or two every couple of days) then be bold! Back yourself to sell the 100 – get the better unit price and give yourself a better chance of making a profit. It might not work, but 9 times out of 10 it will. It’s the same with upcoming cons – keep a record of what you sell at each convention you go to & use that to base order numbers on for your next project.
Engage with your printer & be honest about your situation – don’t be afraid to ask for credit as long as you know that you’ll definitely be able to square the debt. An example: I had a client a few weeks ago who told me they wanted to get a decent number of comics, but they couldn’t afford to until payday, which would be after the convention they were attending. OK, that’s bad planning, but they seemed like good people, I liked their book, we’d had a lot of back and forth on email. Fundamentally, I believed I could trust them, so I took a chance and arranged a 50/50 payment schedule with them. Which worked out perfectly. No regrets there at all – they got their books at a decent cost per unit, I got to help them out, and the company got paid. Now I’m not saying that every printer will work in the same way (hell, I’m not even saying that I will all the time!) but asking the question, as long as you explain your reasoning, isn’t going to hurt.
At this point I should probably talk about the opposite problem – ordering way too many of your book because you’re a rampant egotist who backs their talent far too much. But curiously that never seems to come up…
This one comes up a lot, especially for first timers. Do you know how long it’s going to take to print your comics? What if there are unforeseen technical hiccups (which there will be – we’ll get to that in a minute)? You need to make sure you’ve factored in time to get your project to print and delivered back before you need it if you’re going to remain calm. Ask your printer when you agree on your quote how long it’ll take. Then double what they tell you. Congratulations – you have now left enough time to ensure that you get your stuff back without inducing stress-related heart attacks in everyone involved. You’ve also given yourself a much better chance of getting back books that are perfect because they haven’t been rushed through. Well done you.
You need to consider every reasonable factor. Are you planning on asking for a physical proof? OK, well that needs to be mentioned as soon as possible when discussing the quote. Not only will it affect pricing, it will also add days to your lead time. Your printer is almost certainly not going to be factoring in a physical proof unless you ask them directly, because they’re pretty rare beasts these days. If you have an inflexible deadline (a launch party, or a convention appearance, for example) you need to agree your schedule as early as you can and make sure you stick to it.
The factor that has the greatest impact on schedule snafus, without a doubt, is…
OK, this is your first go-round printing a comic. So I’m going to let you in on a secret:
You’re going to screw something up.
OK, OK, maybe it’s not your first go-round. Maybe you’ve got a couple of books under your belt and you’re just reading this post for the japes. Here’s another secret:
You’re still going to screw something up.
There’s nothing wrong with that! Printing is an incredibly complex business, and comic printing is particularly fraught with pitfalls for small press types. We’ve printed hundreds of comics, maybe thousands (UPDATE: I counted, it’s thousands – thanks everyone!), and in all that time nobody ever got everything right first time. Stop stressing about being perfect & get your files into your printer’s hands as quickly as you can so that they can get to work on fixing them up. That’s what we’re here for (it’s also why you should use a specialist comic printer). The key here, as with everything I’ve said, is to communicate. If you’re worried about a thing – ask your printer. If you don’t understand a concept or a bit of jargon – ask your printer. If you need advice on places to sell, or strategies for selling, or setting up your Kickstarter – ask your printer. If they’re a good printer they’ll be happy to give you personally tailored answers, even if you think the questions are a bit dumb. If they’re not happy to answer your questions, or can’t do so to your satisfaction, then you need a new printer. If only I could suggest one for you…
The most typical technical issues we encounter are to do with bleeds and (in perfect bound books) clearance from the spine. Sometimes these are trivial fixes which we’ll handle in an hour or two for you – you’ll probably never even know we did it. Sometimes, though, they’ll either be complex fixes or else they’ll be things we can’t fix on your behalf (we’ll tell you how, and offer all the assistance we can, though). If you’re unlucky enough to fall into this bracket then you’re going to need to brace yourself for another day or two of lead time.
There isn’t room here (well, there is, it’s the Internet, but you won’t keep reading. I’m surprised you’re still reading this far, to be honest) to cover all the potential technical issues that might come up. Realistically, though, you’re not going to come up with a problem we haven’t seen and solved a million times before. So I’ll close out by repeating once more – get your files into your printer’s hands as quick as you can (even WIP files are helpful for nipping problems in the bud) & let us deal with the technical side of things. You go get back to doing what you do best – creating awesome comics. That’s the best advice I’ve got for you.
Just reading this makes me want to get printing! Funny read you sound like a cool dude!
Best work on my comic book!
Great article there. A real eye opener and page turner. I now have a greater insight as to what is important, and what is actually required… With all this information I should be able to present my first comic.
How ’bout if we want to print just one copy. As say, a personal kind of comic. I’ve been drawing up a few drafts of a post-apocalyptic thaang as a Christmas present for my boyfriend. It’d be easy to just… do the one copy, right?
This is exciting!
This is, believe it or not, the topic of my next article….
Easy enough, but super expensive. If you drop us an email with the specs to firstname.lastname@example.org I’ll get back to you with some ideas and suggestions.
I’ve been printing comics before, and I love the other printer I already use, but just to take a look around I got on the internet and started to look for more… And there you are. After hours of looking through different printers, you’re by far the most entertaining and wonderful one! Can’t wait to print my next comic here!
Oh, you. You’ll make us blush…
Very helpfull. 🙂
Great article! I’m here upon a friend’s recommendation and I’m already pretty pleased with her, and my, choice. I’ll definitely be in touch soon to discuss comicy stuff!
Love your website! Sounds like great advice and your informal style of writing is very refreshing. Came here just to get a quote for printing a comic and now I can’t stop reading all your blog posts 😀
You’re too kind!
Brilliant blog post. Quick question, since this article was written had technology advanced to such a state that comic books can now be done using print on demand? (POD)
I’ve done POD a few times for other books I’ve done but never for comics (yes it’s my first comic book).
Is POD a service you offer too?
Yes and no… That’s helpful, isn’t it? A little more elaborately: yes you can certainly find people out there that will do POD printing for comics, but not us. We’ve looked at it, but in the end we’re not comfortable enough with the quality of the output that you get for an affordable rate to offer this as a service. We’d rather stick to the quality people have come to expect than introduce a service that just isn’t quite there (in our eyes at least).
Sorry to be the bearer of bad news!
BLESS THIS POST! BLESS THIS COMPANY! incredibly helpful and motivating!? Thanking you.
Great article, THANK YOU! Really helpful in so many ways, please keep writing these articles (I read the one about book sizes as well, very helpful). There’s one thing I don’t agree on though – that you “cannot write”. This could be a very boring read, but it wasn’t.